If you’re searching for the best pizza in Kihei, you don’t actually have to stay in Kihei to find it. Just 5 minutes south in Wailea-Makena, Manoli’s Pizza Company consistently earns praise from locals and visitors as one of the top spots for pizza in Kihei and surrounding areas.
Whether you’re craving a casual lunch, a relaxed dinner with ocean views, or quick Kihei pizza delivery to your hotel or condo, Manoli’s delivers an experience that rivals the best pizza on Maui.
Manoli’s Pizza Company is located in the heart of Wailea-Makena, just a 5-minute drive from Kihei. Many visitors staying in Kihei, Andaz Maui, or surrounding vacation rentals make the short trip specifically for Manoli’s thin-crust pizzas, handcrafted cocktails, and stunning sunset views.
It’s close enough to be convenient, but far enough to feel like a special destination dining experience.
If you’ve been Googling “pizza near me”, “best pizza near Kihei,” or “best Mediterranean food” this is the place locals and visitors agree is worth the trip.
Manoli’s offers flexible dining options:
Dine-in
Online ordering for takeout & delivery
One guest shared:
“Great delivery that was super quick (under 30 minutes) to our hotel at the Andaz Maui. The pizza was superb and the day-old leftovers were almost better.”
Multiple reviewers rave about Manoli’s crust:
“Nice thin crust pizza with a generous portion of toppings. Just perfect.”
Popular options include pepperoni, artichoke & onion, and fully custom creations.
One fan put it simply:
“Maybe the best pizza I’ve ever had. Pepperoni, artichoke and onion. Yum!”
While pizza is the star, the menu also features:
One review noted:
“It’s an eclectic menu ranging from gyros to pizza and everything we had we enjoyed. Surprisingly, they have one of the best mai tais on the island.”
This makes Manoli’s a standout among Italian restaurants in Kihei and the Wailea area.
Guests consistently point out Manoli’s value:
“Great food and a great experience at an affordable price.”
For families, couples, and groups, you get top-tier flavor without resort-level price pressure.
Manoli’s atmosphere fits any occasion.
Families love:
Couples enjoy:
One guest shared:
“Views of the golf course and the sunset over the ocean capped off a delightful evening.”
And another added:
“This place is so underrated! One of our favorite spots to come for delicious, comforting Italian food on vacation.”
If you’re searching for:
Manoli’s checks every box:
As one guest perfectly summed up:
“In my opinion, the best pizza on the rock.”
If you’re staying in or around Kihei and wondering where to eat near Kihei, make the short drive south to Wailea-Makena and experience Manoli’s for yourself.
Pro tip: Make a reservation for sunset hours or place your delivery order early during peak dinner times.
Once you try it, you’ll understand why so many visitors say it’s the best pizza on Maui, and why they come back every time they visit the island.